
The moment when you realize you have a pantheon is weird.
It all started innocently enough. I created shapeshifters with water-based magic. Greco-Roman and Arthurian fantasy were overdone at the time I began writing, so I elected to have a Norse-inspired fantasy world. I like cold and darkness, vague ideas about Odin and Loki and Freya hung out in the back of my mind, and I decided I was ready to roll.
Then my MMC said it.
“I’m no saint.”
Wait a second. Saints belong to a much later pantheon.
So I removed that line (small sob), control F’d “saint,” deleted two more occurrences, and moved on.
But then I couldn’t stop seeing the anachronisms. My characters used the Gregorian calendar. They celebrated Christian holidays. I had multiple character names closely tied to major figures in the One Dude religions, and my magic system could very, very generously be described as half-assed.
I realized I had to build my own version of the Norse Pantheon and three episodes of Marvel’s Avengers just isn’t going to cut as a research source.
As a librarian, I have spent time researching with published works, unpublished archives, and material culture. Researching well is one of my special interests. I’ve got this!
…Maybe?
Here’s the thing. The Norse mythology and religion that I want to work with, the pre-Christian tradition, was an oral tradition. It was written down by medieval Christians, who put their Christianity spin on the gods and their exploits. None of the surviving accounts describe ancient Norse religious practices in detail, either. So we have two main stories—eddas—describing gods written down in the 12th century, some slim accounts of ancient practices from the same time, archaeology, and nine hundred years of fanfiction.
I knew about the whole comic-book turned movie thing. But I got all excited when I found print sources, in English, published online because they’re old enough to be in the public domain. Oh crap, they’re written by Victorians.
Those damn Victorians. Could they not with the abridging, and the sanitizing, and the clutching their machine-lace collars? They were already working with a version of the Norse pantheon sanitized by early medieval Christians. Then they had to remake the Norse world in their image.
I would also like to add no thanks to the contemporary shitty British-American author for being a complete creep and writing one of the definitive books for a lay audience on my mythology.
I could have tried harder, I could have gone to the local state university and gotten a community card and done research there…the thought of their parking alone made me want to gnash my teeth and weep.
Weakling that I am, I did my best with a public library/Bookman’s combo. It was…ok?
I have a small pantheon that belongs to the shapeshifters. A smaller one belonging to humans. An outline of the relationship between the sets of gods. A tiny bestiary of magical animals. A rudimentary calendar. Some magical practices (or malpractices as the case may be).
But as a failed academic I can’t call the reading I did to get here proper research.
So I am at the end of a book and in the middle of a research process. I have a stockpile of various editions of mythologies, some nonfiction about the Viking era, and a small amount of common sense. In the next few months, I need to dig into all these resources, make notes, and cross-reference.
I want a pantheon of gods whose powers and motivation can carry a three-book series through MAJOR MAGICAL EVENTS without readers going “but I thought you said…” I want a system of worship and magical practice rooted in modern scholars’ best understanding of my ancestors’ practices. I want my inventions to be built on knowledge, not some misconception that has been repeated until it’s taken as fact.
If I can build a more solid understanding of pagan religious practice between now and handing this book off to an editor, I think I will feel confident enough to turn my focus to book two. Cross your fingers I can scrape together enough titles between my home library and the public library (this includes interlibrary loan. We must not forget interlibrary loan). Otherwise you’ll be reading the news about the woman who got in a fender bender in a local university parking lot, lost it and started screaming about pantheons.